The Edit and Timber hosting have been discontinued. More information available on our about page.
The Edit is now part of Timber Hosting.
Getting meaningful, candid feedback on your podcast episodes is difficult, especially for indie podcasters working without professional teams behind them. We’re trying to change that with a private Discord community called #the-edit. It’s here to help you improve your show with feedback from industry pros that goes beyond “sounds great!”
How it works
Podcast industry professionals will listen carefully to your audio and give you kind, thoughtful, important advice (visible only to a small group of peers) to help you improve your show.
Cohorts will stay small as The Edit grows. There’s a lot to learn from reading feedback on other people’s podcasts and not just your own, but we’ll keep group sizes small because we want the group to feel supportive and not like putting your baby on exhibit.
Now the only way to get The Edit is to subscribe to Timber Hosting (you don’t actually have to host your show on Timber, but buying hosting is the cost of entry). You get 2 edits on your show per year and full access to the Discord community.
Subscribe to Timber Hosting to receive 2 edits per year and full access to the community. Access includes a 14 day free trial
The feedback we provide is high-level, but covers a bunch of important issues, among them:
- Recording notes (any sound quality issues)
- Soundscape (notes on music, sound design, and aural feel)
- Personality (notes on host chemistry, humor, likability)
- Stickiness (what’s keeping listeners engaged and where listeners might lose you)
- Landmines (are there any no-nos like making blanket statements about a groups of people)
- Journalism notes (any journalistic concerns where fact checking or additional research might be suggested?)
- Story notes (how’s the storytelling? Is it immersive, shareable, can you follow it?)
- Format notes (intro/outro/sections sound good and make sense and fit?)
- Writing notes (if parts of the show are scripted, does the script need writing improvements?)
Meet the Timber Reviewers
Our group of professionals includes tastemakers and experienced audio producers.
What people are saying
Jonathan Hall (participant): “Wow. That’s amazing feedback. Thanks! I’ll get that book now. I’ve been looking for good reading material on how to interview.”
Mindy Petersen (participant): “I especially liked your suggestion about drawing out the guest on their own feelings on the topic. I saw your comments in time to use this tip in an interview today.😊
Celine Teo-Blockey (participant): “Will be back! But just wanted to say thank you both for taking the time. Love this editing room.”
Jim Collison on Ask the Podcast Coach: “Dave, this may be a really good way for 20 bucks to get some honest feedback, to get beyond your survey. Cause you’re not going to get it in most cases. So this would be a great idea … for 20 bucks!?”
Shreya Sharma from Inside Podcasting: “This could be useful for all independent podcasters seeking to learn and grow in the space.”
If you haven’t heard of the concept of “the edit” before, listen to Jessica Abel describe it in this episode of Out on the Wire. Simply put, it’s a group meeting where everyone listens for ways to improve the first draft of a show and gives the show’s producer notes.